Classic Christmas CD's to me (laugh all you want at how these all would belong in the Contemporary Adult Christian music genre, but they're the ones who capture Christmas the most for me and they have since I was little):

Amy Grant--
A Christmas Album
Home for Christmas
A Christmas to Remember
Michael W. Smith--
Christmastime
Steven Curtis Chapman--
Music of Christmas
Avalon--
Joy
Jim Brickman--
The Gift
Point of Grace--
A Christmas Story

and, I still love a good ol' Mariah Carey Christmas, Harry Connick Jr., Frank Sinatra, Martina McBride, and many more...however, I do not currently have those CD's and wish I did. My sis and I reminisced last night how we used to listen to all of our classic Christmas records while decorating or making cookies and I love those memories so much! I miss those records!

For those of you who know me well...REALLY REALLY well, you know that Gloria first came out while listening to "Sleigh Ride" from Amy Grant's A Christmas Album...that memory will always hold a dear place in my heart. :-)